Metodo

International Studies in Phenomenology and Philosophy

Journal | Volume | Article

216597

Doing away with the agential bias

agency and patiency in health monitoring applications

Nils-Frederic Wagner

pp. 135-154

Abstract

Mobile health devices pose novel questions at the intersection of philosophy and technology. Many such applications not only collect sensitive data, but also aim at persuading users to change their lifestyle for the better. A major concern is that persuasion is paternalistic as it intentionally aims at changing the agent's actions, chipping away at their autonomy. This worry roots in the philosophical conviction that perhaps the most salient feature of living autonomous lives is displayed via agency as opposed to patiency—our lives go well in virtue of what we do, rather than what happens to us. Being persuaded by a device telling us how to conduct our lives seemingly renders the agent passive, an inert recipient of technological commands. This agential bias, however, has led to a marginalization of patiential characteristics that are just as much part of our lives as are agential characteristics. To appreciate the inherent interlocking of acting and being acted upon, it is vital to acknowledge that agency and patiency are correlates, not mutually exclusive opposites. Furthermore, it is unclear whether an action can only count as agential so long as its causes are internal. Drawing on the extended mind and extended will framework, I argue that mHealth applications merely serve as volitional aids to the agent's internal cognition. Autonomously set goals can be achieved more effectively via technology. To be persuaded by an mHealth device does not mainly—let alone exclusively—emphasize patiency; on the contrary, it can be an effective tool for technologically enhancing agency.

Publication details

Published in:

Mittelstadt Brent (2019) The ethics of biomedical "Big Data" analytics. Philosophy & Technology 32 (1).

Pages: 135-154

DOI: 10.1007/s13347-018-0313-7

Full citation:

Wagner Nils-Frederic (2019) „Doing away with the agential bias: agency and patiency in health monitoring applications“. Philosophy & Technology 32 (1), 135–154.