Metodo

International Studies in Phenomenology and Philosophy

Journal | Volume | Article

167419

The creative moment of scientific apprehension

understanding the consummation of scientific explanation through dewey and peirce

Mark Dietrich Tschaepe

pp. n/a

Abstract

Scientific explanation is both instrumental and consummatory. When we experience scientific explanation in its consummation, we experience what I have deemed a creative moment of scientific apprehension, which is an important aspect of creativity that comes at the end of inquiry and contributes to the development of future inquiry. Because scientific explanation is commonly cleaved from aesthetic experience, this moment of creativity has been neglected in both analyses of scientific practice and analyses of aesthetic experience. By synthesizing John Dewey’s conceptions of scientific explanation and aesthetic experience with Charles S. Peirce’s categories, this moment of scientific inquiry is revealed and understood as a fundamental part of our creative reasoning process. In order to argue that scientific explanation is both instrumental and consummatory, Dewey’s instrumental conception of scientific explanation is provided, which includes why science is so often considered as separated from aesthetic experience. A general overview of Dewey’s conception of aesthetic experience and the common division conceived between scientific experience and that of aesthetics is also provided. Reasons are then supplied to reconsider scientific experience as having an aesthetic dimension, especially with regard to scientific explanations and the creative moment of scientific apprehension, which is followed by a brief discussion concerning how recognition of this moment reveals an important aspect of creative reasoning that is to be understood as a part of our experience through what Peirce referred to as firstness and secondness. Analyzing the aesthetic experience of scientific explanations against the backdrop of Dewey’s conceptions of aesthetics and science, combined with Peirce’s categories, accounts for that creative moment of scientific apprehension in which a scientific explanation takes on the quality of kalos, or sense of general harmony, that inspires reverie and future inquiry.

Publication details

Published in:

(2013) Pragmatism and creativity. European Journal of Pragmatism and American Philosophy 5 (1).

DOI: 10.4000/ejpap.578

Full citation:

Dietrich Tschaepe Mark (2013) „The creative moment of scientific apprehension: understanding the consummation of scientific explanation through dewey and peirce“. European Journal of Pragmatism and American Philosophy 5 (1), n/a.